AQL is not the percentage of defects accepted in a lot: it is the quality level the supplier must ensure on average across lots. It is chosen for each defect class, based on how much that defect costs and weighs along the supply chain. As a starting point, CTic uses 0.65 / 1.5 / 4.0 for critical, major and minor defects.
What AQL really means
ISO 2859-1 defines AQL as the worst tolerable quality level for the process average. A plan with AQL 1.5 accepts with high probability lots with about 1.5% defective pieces or fewer; it does not guarantee that every accepted lot is below that threshold. This is why AQL must be read together with the sample size and the switching rules between normal and tightened inspection.
Factors that drive the choice
- Risk to the user. A defect that can injure or contaminate requires a very low AQL or a 100% check of that characteristic.
- Downstream cost of the defect. An out-of-spec neck that stops the filling line costs far more than the part itself: treat it strictly even if the consumer never sees it.
- Visibility at the point of sale. Cosmetic defects on cartons and primary bottles weigh more on brand image than defects on hidden components.
- Supplier history. A new supplier or one with recent complaints justifies tighter AQLs; a stable one may move to reduced inspection.
- Specification and agreements. The AQL must be written in the supply specification, together with the defect list: it has to be the same for whoever produces and whoever inspects.
Examples for cosmetic packaging
These examples are indicative: each project must be assessed on product, process and supplier.
| Component | Critical | Major | Minor |
|---|---|---|---|
| Glass bottle | 0.65 or lower | 1.0–1.5 | 2.5–4.0 |
| Pump / spray | 0.65 or lower | 1.0 | 2.5–4.0 |
| Cap, closure | 0.65 | 1.5 | 4.0 |
| Carton, label | 0.65 | 1.5–2.5 | 4.0–6.5 |
Watch the mandatory texts. A label or carton with wrong INCI, warnings or batch code is not a cosmetic defect: classify it by risk, and it often needs a dedicated check, not just sampling.
Inspection level and AQL: two different choices
The level (I, II, III) decides how many pieces to inspect; the AQL decides how many defects to allow. Raising the level improves the plan's ability to tell good lots from poor ones, without changing the AQL. Level II remains the most common starting point.
Common mistakes
- Reading AQL 1.5 as "I accept 1.5% defectives in every lot".
- Using a single AQL for everything instead of one per defect class.
- Choosing the AQL without a defect list shared with the supplier.
- Never changing severity: the switching rules are part of the AQL system.
See the effect of the AQL
The calculator opens on a lot of 10,000 pieces with the standard AQLs: change them and see how Ac and Re vary.