← Guides

Critical, major and minor defects

How to classify defects by their consequences, with cosmetic packaging examples and the defect list.

Guide · 5-minute read

A defect is classified by its consequences, not by how visible it is. Critical: it may create a hazard for the user or breach a legal requirement. Major: it impairs the function or use of the product. Minor: it does not affect use, but departs from the agreed standard.

The three classes in practice

ClassQuestion to askTypical consequence
CriticalCan it injure, contaminate or make the product non-compliant with the law?Lot on hold, possible recall
MajorDoes the product work poorly, leak or stop the filling line?Complaint, line stop, scrap
MinorIs it just an imperfection that does not change use?Image damage if repeated

Examples for cosmetic packaging

These examples are indicative: the final class depends on product, market and specification.

ComponentCriticalMajorMinor
Glass bottleCrack, chip, glass fragments insideNeck out of spec, seal compromisedSurface bubbles, light marks
Pump / spraySharp parts, components coming looseNo dispensing, dose out of tolerance, leakageLight scratches, small non-functional flash
Cap, closureFragments or flash that may end up in the productDoes not close, does not screw on, leakageShade difference within limits, light marks
Carton, labelWrong or missing INCI, warnings or batch codeCarton that does not close or cannot be erectedSmall stains or print defects

How to build the defect list

  1. List the defects per component, with a clear name and a short description.
  2. Assign the class using the question about consequences, not appearance.
  3. Define how to inspect: visually, with a gauge, leak or functional test, and under which conditions (light, distance, viewing time).
  4. Attach limit samples: photos or physical pieces showing "still acceptable" and "already a defect".
  5. Share it with the supplier and attach it to the specification, together with the AQL per class.

Rule of thumb: if two inspectors classify the same piece differently, the defect list is not clear enough yet. Limit samples settle most doubts.

Common mistakes

  • Classifying by how noticeable the defect is instead of by its consequences.
  • Counting several defects on the same piece as several defective pieces: for AQL counting you count the piece, in the class of its most serious defect.
  • Leaving classification to each inspector's experience, without a written list.

From classification to plan

Set an AQL for each class and get sample size, Ac and Re right away.

Open the calculator →

Guide by CTic Consulting · reference: ISO 2859-1:1999. For contractual use, the text of the standard prevails.