A defect is classified by its consequences, not by how visible it is. Critical: it may create a hazard for the user or breach a legal requirement. Major: it impairs the function or use of the product. Minor: it does not affect use, but departs from the agreed standard.
The three classes in practice
| Class | Question to ask | Typical consequence |
|---|---|---|
| Critical | Can it injure, contaminate or make the product non-compliant with the law? | Lot on hold, possible recall |
| Major | Does the product work poorly, leak or stop the filling line? | Complaint, line stop, scrap |
| Minor | Is it just an imperfection that does not change use? | Image damage if repeated |
Examples for cosmetic packaging
These examples are indicative: the final class depends on product, market and specification.
| Component | Critical | Major | Minor |
|---|---|---|---|
| Glass bottle | Crack, chip, glass fragments inside | Neck out of spec, seal compromised | Surface bubbles, light marks |
| Pump / spray | Sharp parts, components coming loose | No dispensing, dose out of tolerance, leakage | Light scratches, small non-functional flash |
| Cap, closure | Fragments or flash that may end up in the product | Does not close, does not screw on, leakage | Shade difference within limits, light marks |
| Carton, label | Wrong or missing INCI, warnings or batch code | Carton that does not close or cannot be erected | Small stains or print defects |
How to build the defect list
- List the defects per component, with a clear name and a short description.
- Assign the class using the question about consequences, not appearance.
- Define how to inspect: visually, with a gauge, leak or functional test, and under which conditions (light, distance, viewing time).
- Attach limit samples: photos or physical pieces showing "still acceptable" and "already a defect".
- Share it with the supplier and attach it to the specification, together with the AQL per class.
Rule of thumb: if two inspectors classify the same piece differently, the defect list is not clear enough yet. Limit samples settle most doubts.
Common mistakes
- Classifying by how noticeable the defect is instead of by its consequences.
- Counting several defects on the same piece as several defective pieces: for AQL counting you count the piece, in the class of its most serious defect.
- Leaving classification to each inspector's experience, without a written list.
From classification to plan
Set an AQL for each class and get sample size, Ac and Re right away.